Total Civilian Firearm Prohibition ActCasualty estimate for the bill's sponsor

Congratulations, Senator. You saved America.

You banned all guns, and now there will be no more shootings, ever again.

Well, almost none. Rich countries with almost no guns still have gun homicides every year. At their rates, a gun-free America of 340 million would still see:

Japan's rate (0.003 per 100,000)about 10 a year
England and Wales (0.049)about 167 a year
The Netherlands (0.16)about 544 a year

And those countries never had 415 million guns to make disappear.

You proudly stood against violence, quietly suspended the Fourth Amendment, and refused to be influenced by the nefarious advocates of violence who love dead children. The nation's brave police officers now set out to enforce your bill. Here are the results.

Let's get it done, Senator!

Here is how you do it. Every step is already in your bill; this is just the order it happens in.

  1. Sign it. The cameras flash. Every privately owned gun in America is contraband from this moment, and the owners have an amnesty to hand them in.
  2. Build the list. There is no national gun registry; federal law has forbidden one since 1986. So you build it: dealer purchase forms going back decades, carry permits, hunting licenses, tips from neighbors, ex-wives and coworkers. Mail every name a compliance order.
  3. Get the warrants. Every name that doesn't comply gets a search warrant, and a judge has to sign each one. Courts that already run years behind take on tens of millions more.
  4. Send the teams. Every address on the list belongs, by definition, to someone you believe is armed and refusing. So you send armored tactical teams, before dawn, the way drug raids are done. Some of the lists are wrong, and some of the doors belong to people who sold their guns years ago or never owned one.
  5. Count. Most people open the door. Some don't.

Dead Americans: 0

While you've been reading this page: 0 more. One every —, day and night, until the last door is opened.

The wall

0gun owners shot in their own homes, nearly all with clean records
0police officers who knocked because you told them to
0spouses, children and neighbors in the next room
0people in homes with no guns at all, raided by mistake

Your bill, beside America's wars

Just reported

Names and lives are invented; who they are follows the numbers above.

    Meanwhile, at the emergency department

    A board like this, in every trauma center in the country, every working day of enforcement.

    ED tracking boardTrauma: CODE YELLOW
    BedPatientInjuryStatus
    gunshot patients arriving every working day, on top of the roughly 220 the country already treats each day
    times the normal national load of gunshot wounds, for as long as the raids run
    new gunshot patients a day for each of the country's 216 Level I trauma centers. Alaska, Idaho, Montana, South Dakota and Wyoming have none.
    in initial hospital bills alone, at $31,000 a gunshot admission and $9,000 for each patient who dies. Readmissions, rehab and lifetime care are extra.
    first responders likely to develop depression or PTSD from it: 30% of the country's 4.6 million police, firefighters and medics, against 20% of everyone else. Every nurse who mops a trauma bay at 3 a.m. comes home with it too.

    Now look at what's on your fork, Senator.

    Leticia is a single black mother at 33, with one daughter, Abigail, who is six years old. She originally bought a Glock handgun since, on a CNA’s pay, she can’t really afford to live in a nice area, and due to recent news, she’s reluctant to trust police to protect her. Her mother and father call her regularly. Her brother helps care for her daughter, ever since the death of Leticia’s husband due to cancer. He sleeps on her couch due to the long commute, from time to time.

    Officer Kemp is a 26-year-old white man who has been a police officer for two years. He is a married man, but he and his wife have decided that kids just aren’t for them, so they don’t have kids. They love to take care of his nieces and nephews anyway. He’s a good cop who cares about people, and tries to do his job right. Since the passage of the Total Civilian Firearm Prohibition Act, he has been forced to join a tactical team if he wants to keep his job.

    Your office sends Leticia a demand to turn in her firearm, though you aren’t sure if she still has it. As a busy single mother in an apartment with unreliable mail delivery, it’s not really clear if it ever gets to her, or if it is simply ignored, or perhaps forgotten. She is then sent a notice to appear in court to answer for her silence. Whether that one reaches her is just as unclear. For some reason, she fails to appear.

    Officer Kemp and his team gather their guns and body armor and prepare to make entry into Leticia’s home to arrest her and seize her firearms. They assemble at 0300 on Sunday, on a cold morning in the dark. Three minutes later, they force entry to the residence, since the suspect is known to be armed. Officer Kemp enters the small apartment first.

    Leticia is terrified, concerned that her apartment has just been broken into. Abigail is asleep in her mother’s room. Leticia does what every American gun owner has been trained to do, and reaches for her gun. She fires four shots at the unknown men who broke down her door. She strikes Officer Kemp four times, twice in the face and twice in the torso. He is killed instantly. His wife will never see his face again, since he must have a closed casket funeral. She’s awake. Officer Kemp always texts her before a warrant, since they’re dangerous. She’s waiting for him to confirm it’s over. These raids only take a few minutes. When he doesn’t text her back, she knows already that something very bad has happened.

    The tactical team responds in the only way they ever could, and returns a massive hail of gunfire. Miraculously, since all of these men are good shots, even though Leticia’s daughter is in the room, the child is unharmed. Physically, anyway. Psychologically, nobody can say, since she has just watched her mother torn apart by gunfire, as Leticia is hit by over thirty rifle rounds inside of ten seconds. Leticia has never had a criminal record, and neither has Officer Kemp.

    Leticia’s brother, Kevin, asleep on the couch, awakens to gunfire, and instantly begins to run towards Abigail to protect her. Another tactical officer, spotting a fleeing man in the mayhem, slams him to the ground, breaking his wrist. He screams for his sister and niece as he’s cuffed. The officers search his pockets for weapons, and find a small baggie of marijuana. Kevin never smokes around Abigail, but his job as an Amazon employee is stressful. Being able to unwind a bit seems harmless. But since marijuana is illegal in this jurisdiction, Kevin is taken into custody and charged with drug possession. He realizes he’s never going to see Leticia again, and is arrested without being able to say goodbye to Abigail, who is screaming for him.

    Officer Kemp’s widow has begun to panic.

    Will you be the one to knock at her door and tell her that Officer Kemp is dead?

    They are invented. The apartment is not: at the settings above, your bill ends this way — times.

    Your assumptions

    About 42% of 131 million US households (Gallup, 2023).
    New York's 2013 assault weapon registration drew an estimated 4 to 5%.
    Each team serves 4 homes a working day.
    Wrong addresses, stale purchase records, false tips. No national data exists; in 2003 a 57-year-old New York woman, Alberta Spruill, died after police threw a flash grenade into the wrong apartment on a bad tip.
    Australia paid about A$833 a gun in 1996; New Zealand about NZ$1,700 in 2019.
    Of people in searched homes who used marijuana in the past year, in states where it is still illegal.
    The rest get probation, fines or plea deals, and still carry the felony.

    What else your bill did

    • Every one of those homes gets entered and searched. That is either tens of millions of individual warrants, each needing probable cause a judge has to sign, or the warrant requirement is gone. In practice, you have repealed the Fourth Amendment, and nobody gives that power back.
    • Americans made felons the day it passed, for owning what was legal the day before. of them had no felony record.
    • The Fourth Amendment, againIt was written against exactly this: British general warrants and writs of assistance that let the Crown's officers search colonists' homes for contraband without naming what or why. Your bill brings back the house-to-house search for contraband, at a scale the Crown never managed. And once the teams, the lists and the habit exist, the next senator can point them at anything.
    • close relatives left grieving: about nine for every death (a grandparent, parent, sibling, spouse or child). Among them, widows and widowers.
    • children, at the very least, who lose a parent. About 3 in 10 American adults are raising a child under 18; this counts one child per parent, which is low. That is full classrooms of 20 children, every desk with a child in it whose mother or father your bill killed.
    • September 11ths. The attacks killed 2,977 people and remade the country for a generation; your bill does it again and again, one front door at a time.
    • years of American school shootings, at Everytown's count for the 2023 to 2024 school year: 36 killed in 144 incidents of gunfire on K-12 grounds. That count is deliberately broad (every round fired on school property, including suicides, accidents and police shootings), and your bill still outpaces it by that many years.
    • more people shot and survive: for every gun homicide, about 2.4 people are hospitalized with gunshot wounds. Spinal cords, colostomy bags, amputations, a lifetime of surgeries.
    • of those relatives belong to the officers you sent.
    • new prisons, at the 650-bed average of the existing system, to hold the new felons you lock up ( of them at the rate set below). That is times the bed capacity of every state and federal prison in the country.
    • The criminals keep theirsOf prisoners who carried a gun during their crime, 9 in 10 did not get it from a store; 43% bought it on the street or the underground market. There is no form, permit or receipt to put them on your list. Your raids find the people who bought legally and filled out the paperwork. The people your bill was supposed to disarm are the ones it cannot find.
    • people charged with marijuana possession because officers searching for guns found it in plain view, which lets them seize and charge anything illegal they see during a lawful search. of them never owned a gun. Pills not in your name, an old warrant, an unlicensed anything: all fair game once the door is open.
    • to pay for the guns turned in, at a gun, plus a year to keep the new prisoners locked up. Nothing in that figure buys back a single life on the wall.
    • new felons is of the voting-age population, against about 4 million Americans barred from voting by a felony today. How many lose the ballot, and for how long, depends on each state's law; in some states it is for life unless a governor restores it. Gun ownership runs 47% among Republicans and 19% among Democrats, so the disenfranchisement would fall heavily on one side.
    • years of every American gun homicide, at 2023's count of 17,927, in the body count of your enforcement plan alone. Against all gun deaths, suicides included (46,728 in 2023), it is years.
    • of the gun owners killed would be women, if they die in proportion to who owns guns (42% of owners are women).
    • That is how many years of today's police line-of-duty killings your enforcement plan spends, at 60 officers a year.
    • of raids, every working day, until the last door is opened.

    The deserved-to-die index

    Maybe they had it coming. Here is what the record says about the kind of people you just killed.

    0%had a felony record. Felons were already barred from owning guns; everyone on the list owned theirs legally until your bill.
    0.023%of Texas concealed handgun licensees were convicted of any crime in 2011, against 0.251% of all Texans: about one-eleventh the rate.
    of the gun owners killed would, at that rate, have been convicted of anything in a given year. Traffic-level offenses included.

    Your verdict, Senator. On average, did they deserve to die?

    The bigot's discount

    Some people only mind the deaths of people like themselves. If that is you, press the people you don't care about. We will take them off your conscience.

    I'm a bigot, so I don't care if these people die:

    And if none of this moves you

    Closer to home

    The same bill, brought down to where you live.

    Since you opened this page, your bill has killed 0 more people. Another name goes on the wall every —.

    dead in
    of them police officers from departments
    homes raided by tactical teams
    raids on homes with no guns in them
    neighbors made felons overnight
    children who lose a parent
    relatives at the funerals

    Each state's share of the national toll follows its share of Americans living in a home with a gun: RAND's household ownership estimates for 2016, applied to 2020 Census population. Most raids, and most deaths, land where most guns are.

    Your street

    no gunshanded them intactical team before dawnraided by mistake, no gunsfuneral

    On the record

    114 lines from bodycam, dashcam, 911 calls, police radio and the people who were there. The bar at the bottom of the page plays them one at a time.

    After the raid · testimony and research

    • “My baby is nowhere near recovering.” Alecia Phonesavanh, after a SWAT flash grenade landed in her 19-month-old son's playpen during a 2014 drug raid in Habersham County, Georgia (ABC News)
    • “My kids jump every time there's a knock at the door.” a father whose family was held at gunpoint in a wrong-house SWAT raid, 2015 (Nation of Change)
    • Seconds after he fired, one thought: “Did I hit him?” Fountain, Colorado police officer Jon Kay, on the seconds after he shot a man (Colorado Springs Gazette, 2018)
    • “Reshyla is still having nightmares, still can't sleep.” Regina Evans, after Chicago police pointed guns at her young daughters in a raid on the wrong home (Good Morning America, 2021)
    • Fatigue, trouble sleeping, recurring thoughts. what officers reported most often after shooting someone, in a federal study of 80 officers and 113 shootings (National Institute of Justice, 2001)
    • “She still doesn't sleep.” an Oklahoma City mother whose 9-year-old walked toward armed officers in a raid on the wrong house (News 9, 2025)
    • Nightmares. Flashbacks. Sirens in his ears for three days. a 22-year police veteran and SWAT operator, after a shooting; he could not talk about it with his own wife, also an officer (Police1)
    • “Every little noise is like, ‘who's out there?’” a Detroit mother after police raided her family's home looking for a man who no longer lived there (WXYZ)
    • Her children dream the SWAT team kills their mother. a Denver family's lawsuit over a wrong-apartment SWAT raid; one daughter still sleeps in her mother's room (Atlanta Black Star, 2025)
    • Nightmares, suicidal thoughts, symptoms that fit PTSD. what people described after law enforcement raids on their homes, in the first study of raids' psychological impact (Traumatology, 2018)
    • She taught her children to respect police. Now they fear them. Ebony Tate, after a Chicago SWAT team raided the wrong home (Fox 32 Chicago)
    • About 1 in 4 had elevated post-traumatic stress. children who had watched a household member arrested and had a recently arrested parent, in a national study (Children and Youth Services Review, 2010)

    Anjanette Young · Chicago, 2019 · wrong-house raid

    • “You’ve got the wrong house. I live alone.” Anjanette Young, a social worker, naked and handcuffed when Chicago police raided the wrong home, 2019 (bodycam, via The Hill)
    • “I’m naked, and you kicked my house in.” Anjanette Young, to the officers (bodycam, via The Hill)
    • “My name is Anjanette Young. What is going on?” Young, as a blanket kept slipping off her while she stood cuffed (bodycam, via the Daily Dot)
    • “I truly believe they would have shot me.” Anjanette Young, later (CBS 2 Chicago, via HuffPost)

    Roger Fortson · Fort Walton Beach, Florida, 2024

    • “Sheriff’s office. Open the door.” an Okaloosa County, Florida deputy at Senior Airman Roger Fortson’s apartment, seconds before firing, 2024 (bodycam, via 11Alive)
    • “Drop the gun! Drop the gun!” the deputy, after the shots; Fortson’s legally owned gun had been pointed at the floor (bodycam, via NBC Miami)
    • “It’s over there.” Roger Fortson, 23, on the floor, about his gun (bodycam, via NBC Miami)
    • “I can’t breathe.” Roger Fortson, according to his family’s lawyer, who cited the girlfriend on FaceTime with him (via Complex)

    Breonna Taylor · Louisville, 2020 · narcotics raid

    • “Somebody kicked in the door and shot my girlfriend.” Kenneth Walker, a licensed gun owner, to 911 after Louisville police raided Breonna Taylor’s apartment, 2020 (WDRB)
    • “Bree, oh my God.” Kenneth Walker, on the same call (WDRB)
    • “I don’t know, she is on the ground right now.” Walker, asked where Breonna Taylor had been shot (911 call, via theGrio)
    • “I can’t stand up because I’m going to pump the blood out.” Sgt. Jonathan Mattingly, shot in the leg in the doorway (interview with ABC News and the Courier Journal, 2020)
    • “Did she have a gun? Was she a shooter?” Mattingly’s first question on waking from surgery the next day (ABC News)
    • “Breonna Taylor is now attached to me for the rest of my life.” Mattingly (ABC News)
    • He thought fellow officers were “being executed.” Det. Brett Hankison, explaining why he fired blindly into the apartment (grand jury recordings, via CNN)

    Amir Locke · Minneapolis, 2022 · no-knock raid

    • “Police! Search warrant!” a Minneapolis SWAT team, seconds before Amir Locke, 22, was shot waking up under a blanket on a couch, 2022 (bodycam, via Mediaite)
    • “He’s got a gun!” an officer, after the shots; Locke had a carry permit and was not named in the warrant (bodycam, via WCCO)
    • “A mother should never have to see her child executed…” Karen Wells, Amir Locke’s mother (ABC News, 2022)
    • “And now his dreams have been destroyed.” Karen Wells (Daily Herald)
    • “My son Amir was a law-abiding citizen who did not have a criminal history.” Andre Locke, his father (ABC News)

    Daniel Shaver · Mesa, Arizona, 2016

    • “Please do not shoot me.” Daniel Shaver, 26, unarmed and sobbing on the floor of a Mesa, Arizona hotel hallway, 2016 (bodycam, via the Dallas Morning News)
    • “If you do that again, we are shooting you.” Sgt. Charles Langley, to Shaver (bodycam transcript, via the Dallas Morning News)
    • “You may not survive it, do you understand me?” the commands before Shaver was shot five times with a rifle (bodycam, via Uproxx)
    • “My kids are absolutely heartbroken, and I can’t fix it.” Laney Sweet, Shaver’s widow and the mother of their two girls (ABC10)

    Philando Castile · Falcon Heights, Minnesota, 2016

    • “Sir, I have to tell you I do have a firearm on me.” Philando Castile, licensed to carry, at a traffic stop in Falcon Heights, Minnesota, 2016 (dashcam, via CNN)
    • “I’m not pulling it out.” Castile, seconds before seven shots (dashcam, via the Star Tribune)
    • “I wasn’t reaching.” Castile, softly, after the shots (dashcam, via Jezebel)
    • “You just killed my boyfriend.” Diamond Reynolds, from the passenger seat (dashcam, via CBS News)
    • “Don’t move, baby.” Reynolds, to her 4-year-old daughter in the back seat (dashcam, via the Tri-State Defender)
    • “I don’t know how many rounds I let out.” Officer Jeronimo Yanez, afterward (dashcam, via Fox 2 Detroit)

    Robert Dotson · Farmington, New Mexico, 2023 · wrong house

    • “Please help, somebody shot my husband!” Kimberly Dotson, after Farmington, New Mexico police went to the wrong house and killed Robert Dotson at his own door, 2023 (bodycam, via The Day)
    • “We cannot figure out how to breathe.” Kimberly Dotson, at a news conference (The Journal)
    • “This ending is just unbelievably tragic.” Farmington Police Chief Steve Hebbe (via KION)

    Sonya Massey · Springfield, Illinois, 2024

    • “Please don’t hurt me though.” Sonya Massey, 36, who had called 911 about a prowler, to the deputies at her Springfield, Illinois door, 2024 (bodycam, via The Root)
    • “Why would we hurt you? You called us.” Deputy Sean Grayson (bodycam, via The Root)
    • “Please God, please God, please God.” Sonya Massey (bodycam, via USA Today)
    • “I rebuke you in the name of Jesus.” Massey, at her stove (bodycam, via the Chicago Reporter)
    • “I’ll f—ing shoot you right in the f—ing face.” Deputy Grayson, drawing his pistol (bodycam, via Capitol News Illinois)
    • “OK, I’m sorry!” Sonya Massey, ducking, seconds before she was shot (bodycam, via USA Today)
    • “That’s a headshot. There’s nothing you can do, man.” Grayson, telling his partner not to bother with the medical kit (bodycam, via AP)

    Atatiana Jefferson · Fort Worth, 2019 · welfare check

    • “Put your hands up, show me your hands.” a Fort Worth officer at Atatiana Jefferson’s back window, then one shot; she was home with her 8-year-old nephew, 2019 (bodycam, via AP)
    • “If I had never dialed the police department, she’d still be alive.” James Smith, the neighbor who asked for a welfare check (AP)
    • “Justice don’t bring my sister back.” Amber Carr, Jefferson’s sister (AP)
    • “My daughter… had her whole life in front of her.” Marquis Jefferson (CBS News)

    Botham Jean · Dallas, 2018

    • “I thought it was my apartment.” off-duty Dallas officer Amber Guyger, 19 times, after shooting Botham Jean in his own apartment, 2018 (911 call, via theGrio)
    • “Get up, man.” Guyger, to Botham Jean, before the dispatcher answered (911 call, via Going Concern)
    • “I’m gonna lose my job.” Guyger, on the same call (AP)
    • “I’m so tired.” Guyger, on the same call (AP)

    Ryan Whitaker · Phoenix, 2020

    • “Why did you guys shoot him?” Brandee Nees, after Phoenix police shot her boyfriend Ryan Whitaker, a licensed gun owner, at his own door, 2020 (bodycam, via Fox 10)
    • “He’s pulled a gun on us, ma’am.” the officer (bodycam, via Fox 10)
    • “Because it’s dark and someone has knocked on the door.” Nees, explaining why he answered armed (bodycam, via Fox 10)
    • “He stepped out of the door, realized it was them, put his hand down.” Steven Whitaker, his brother (Arizona Republic)

    Kenneth Chamberlain Sr. · White Plains, New York, 2011

    • “I’m a 68-year-old man with a heart condition.” Kenneth Chamberlain Sr., a Marine veteran who set off his medical alert in his sleep, to White Plains police at his door, 2011 (LifeAid recording, via Democracy Now!)
    • “I’m telling you I’m OK!” Chamberlain, through the door (LifeAid recording, via Democracy Now!)
    • “I have the White Plains Police Department banging on my door” Chamberlain, to the LifeAid operator (via Truthout)
    • “They have stun guns and shotguns!” Chamberlain (Taser camera, via Democracy Now!)
    • “White Plains police are going to come in here and kill me.” Chamberlain, before they broke down the door and shot him (via Common Dreams)

    Harding Street · Houston, 2019 · no-knock raid

    • “Multiple officers shot … multiple officers shot.” Houston police radio, the 2019 no-knock raid on Harding Street that killed Dennis Tuttle and Rhogena Nicholas (via KPRC)
    • “DOA on Harding.” Houston police radio (via KPRC)
    • “Got three officers hit.” Houston police radio (via KHOU)
    • “I had to get in there because I knew my guys were down.” a 54-year-old officer, shot for the third time in his career (note to his chief, via ABC13)

    Deputy Zackari Parrish · Highlands Ranch, Colorado, 2017

    • “We’ve got three officers hit, one down.” radio traffic, Highlands Ranch, Colorado, New Year’s Eve 2017 (via CBS Colorado)
    • “I still have an officer inside the residence.” radio traffic; Deputy Zackari Parrish, 29, a father of two, was still inside (via CBS Colorado)
    • “They tried to pull him out but were unable to.” Sheriff Tony Spurlock, on the wounded deputies (Denver Post)

    Donovan Lewis · Columbus, Ohio, 2022 · arrest warrant

    • “Donovan, if you don’t come to the door, I’m going to kick it in.” a Columbus, Ohio officer serving an arrest warrant at 2 a.m., 2022; Donovan Lewis, 20, was shot as he sat up in bed (bodycam, via CBS News)
    • “A vape pen that was found on the bed right next to him.” Columbus Police Chief Elaine Bryant, on what was in his hand (via Yahoo News)
    • “As a parent, you know, I sympathize and I grieve with his mother.” Chief Bryant (via BET)

    Ruby Johnson and the Shelton family · Denver, 2022 and 2023 · SWAT searches

    • “When I start thinking about it, tears start coming down.” Ruby Johnson, 77, after a Denver SWAT team searched her home of 40 years on a bad phone-app ping, 2022 (9News)
    • “Don’t hurt us!” the Shelton family, when a Denver SWAT team surrounded the wrong apartment, 2023 (via USA Today)

    Tioga · Philadelphia, 2019 · drug warrant

    • “Shots fired, shots fired.” Philadelphia police radio as narcotics officers served a warrant in Tioga, 2019; six officers were shot (via the Inquirer)
    • “I got an officer shot at this location in the leg!” an officer, to the dispatcher (via the Inquirer)
    • “Nothing short of a miracle that we don’t have multiple officers killed today.” Philadelphia’s police commissioner (via Firehouse)

    Florence, South Carolina, 2018 · search warrant

    • “Have an officer down.” a dispatcher as deputies served a warrant near Florence, South Carolina, 2018; seven officers were shot, two died (via Reuters)
    • “Fire was being shot all over.” Florence County Sheriff Kenney Boone (NPR)
    • “Seemed like it was forever.” Florence Police Chief Allen Heidler, on the wait to reach the wounded (AP)

    Steve Perkins · Decatur, Alabama, 2023

    • “I can’t breathe.” Steve Perkins, dying and handcuffed in his own front yard after a Decatur, Alabama officer shot him during a truck repossession, 2023 (bodycam, via Yahoo News)

    Walter Wallace Jr. · Philadelphia, 2020

    • “He’s mental! He’s mental!” a woman pleading with Philadelphia officers before they shot Walter Wallace Jr. outside his parents’ home, 2020 (bodycam, via The Independent)
    • “You killed my son, you killed my son!” Cathy Wallace, his mother (bodycam, via Philadelphia magazine)
    • “Shoot him.” an unidentified male voice on the bodycam audio (via NPR)

    Win Rozario · Queens, New York, 2024

    • “Please! My mom! Mom! Please! Please stop!” Win Rozario, 19, who had called 911 himself in a mental health crisis, in his family’s Queens kitchen, 2024 (bodycam, via Democracy Now!)
    • “I’m so sorry!” Win Rozario (bodycam, via Democracy Now!)
    • “Get her out of the way!” NYPD officers, as his mother held on to him (bodycam, via AP)
    • “Murdered him in our kitchen without any care for him or us.” the Rozario family’s statement (via Yahoo News)

    Andrew Finch · Wichita, 2017 · hoax call

    • “I heard my son scream, I got up and then I heard a shot.” Lisa Finch, after Wichita police shot her son Andrew, 28, at his door on a hoax call, 2017 (Wichita Eagle, via Newshub)
    • “They didn’t give him any warnings.” Lisa Finch (via NewsChannel 5)
    • “Adelina was made to step over his dying body.” Lisa Finch, on her granddaughter, who saw it happen (via Dazed)
    • “My innocent son being shot through the screen door…” Lisa Finch, to the Wichita City Council (via The Appeal)

    Herman Whitfield III · Indianapolis, 2022

    • “I can’t breathe. I can’t breathe.” Herman Whitfield III, 39, a pianist in a mental health crisis, face-down in his parents’ Indianapolis living room, 2022 (bodycam, via WRTV)
    • “He was saying fire, fire!” his father, Herman Whitfield Jr., who watched (WRTV)
    • “I was just horrified.” his father (WRTV)
    • “I miss his hugs.” his mother, Gladys Whitfield (WRTV)

    Det. Charles Dinwiddie and Marvin Guy · Killeen, Texas, 2014 · no-knock raid

    • “I told Chuck to wake up and keep fighting.” a Killeen, Texas SWAT officer, on Det. Charles Dinwiddie, shot in a 2014 no-knock raid (trial testimony, via KCEN)
    • “With my life.” a fellow officer, asked if he trusted Dinwiddie (testimony, via KCEN)
    • “I knew what I did was wrong.” a Killeen officer, testifying that he put his pistol in Marvin Guy’s mouth after the raid (KCEN)
    • “I never heard “police search warrant.”” Joanna Humfleet, Guy’s neighbor (testimony, via KCEN)
    • “He woke up happy.” Holly Dinwiddie, the detective’s widow (testimony, via Reason)
    • “His wife, his children deserve justice.” Kathryn Dinwiddie, his sister (KCEN)

    Michael Jenkins and Eddie Parker · Rankin County, Mississippi, 2023

    • “I don’t know if I will ever be able to sleep at night.” Eddie Parker, tortured by Rankin County, Mississippi deputies in a warrantless home raid, 2023 (statement, via the Minneapolis Spokesman-Recorder)
    • “I’m so sorry that I caused that. I hate myself for it.” former deputy Hunter Elward, at sentencing, to Michael Jenkins (via the Spokesman-Recorder)
    • “I hate what’s happened to them.” Elward (via Mississippi Today and the New York Times)

    Victoria Lee · Fort Lee, New Jersey, 2024

    • “I’m gonna break the door down.” Fort Lee, New Jersey officer Tony Pickens Jr., after a brother called 911 for help with his sister’s mental health crisis, 2024 (bodycam, via NPR)
    • “Who wants to go lethal” officers in the hallway, before Victoria Lee, 25, was shot holding a water jug (bodycam, via CNN)

    Do you still think you're a good person?

    Where the numbers come from

    No country has ever tried to seize guns door to door at American scale, so there is no data on the death toll. Every casualty rate is a slider for that reason. The point stands at any setting you can defend: a ban is only as real as the people sent to enforce it.

    On the record
    “You’ve got the wrong house. I live alone.” Anjanette Young, a social worker, naked and handcuffed when Chicago police raided the wrong home, 2019 (bodycam, via The Hill)“Sheriff’s office. Open the door.” an Okaloosa County, Florida deputy at Senior Airman Roger Fortson’s apartment, seconds before firing, 2024 (bodycam, via 11Alive)“Somebody kicked in the door and shot my girlfriend.” Kenneth Walker, a licensed gun owner, to 911 after Louisville police raided Breonna Taylor’s apartment, 2020 (WDRB)“Police! Search warrant!” a Minneapolis SWAT team, seconds before Amir Locke, 22, was shot waking up under a blanket on a couch, 2022 (bodycam, via Mediaite)“Please do not shoot me.” Daniel Shaver, 26, unarmed and sobbing on the floor of a Mesa, Arizona hotel hallway, 2016 (bodycam, via the Dallas Morning News)“Sir, I have to tell you I do have a firearm on me.” Philando Castile, licensed to carry, at a traffic stop in Falcon Heights, Minnesota, 2016 (dashcam, via CNN)“Please help, somebody shot my husband!” Kimberly Dotson, after Farmington, New Mexico police went to the wrong house and killed Robert Dotson at his own door, 2023 (bodycam, via The Day)“Please don’t hurt me though.” Sonya Massey, 36, who had called 911 about a prowler, to the deputies at her Springfield, Illinois door, 2024 (bodycam, via The Root)“Put your hands up, show me your hands.” a Fort Worth officer at Atatiana Jefferson’s back window, then one shot; she was home with her 8-year-old nephew, 2019 (bodycam, via AP)“My baby is nowhere near recovering.” Alecia Phonesavanh, after a SWAT flash grenade landed in her 19-month-old son's playpen during a 2014 drug raid in Habersham County, Georgia (ABC News)“I thought it was my apartment.” off-duty Dallas officer Amber Guyger, 19 times, after shooting Botham Jean in his own apartment, 2018 (911 call, via theGrio)“Why did you guys shoot him?” Brandee Nees, after Phoenix police shot her boyfriend Ryan Whitaker, a licensed gun owner, at his own door, 2020 (bodycam, via Fox 10)“I’m a 68-year-old man with a heart condition.” Kenneth Chamberlain Sr., a Marine veteran who set off his medical alert in his sleep, to White Plains police at his door, 2011 (LifeAid recording, via Democracy Now!)“Multiple officers shot … multiple officers shot.” Houston police radio, the 2019 no-knock raid on Harding Street that killed Dennis Tuttle and Rhogena Nicholas (via KPRC)“We’ve got three officers hit, one down.” radio traffic, Highlands Ranch, Colorado, New Year’s Eve 2017 (via CBS Colorado)“Donovan, if you don’t come to the door, I’m going to kick it in.” a Columbus, Ohio officer serving an arrest warrant at 2 a.m., 2022; Donovan Lewis, 20, was shot as he sat up in bed (bodycam, via CBS News)“When I start thinking about it, tears start coming down.” Ruby Johnson, 77, after a Denver SWAT team searched her home of 40 years on a bad phone-app ping, 2022 (9News)“Shots fired, shots fired.” Philadelphia police radio as narcotics officers served a warrant in Tioga, 2019; six officers were shot (via the Inquirer)“Have an officer down.” a dispatcher as deputies served a warrant near Florence, South Carolina, 2018; seven officers were shot, two died (via Reuters)“My kids jump every time there's a knock at the door.” a father whose family was held at gunpoint in a wrong-house SWAT raid, 2015 (Nation of Change)“I can’t breathe.” Steve Perkins, dying and handcuffed in his own front yard after a Decatur, Alabama officer shot him during a truck repossession, 2023 (bodycam, via Yahoo News)“He’s mental! He’s mental!” a woman pleading with Philadelphia officers before they shot Walter Wallace Jr. outside his parents’ home, 2020 (bodycam, via The Independent)“Please! My mom! Mom! Please! Please stop!” Win Rozario, 19, who had called 911 himself in a mental health crisis, in his family’s Queens kitchen, 2024 (bodycam, via Democracy Now!)“I heard my son scream, I got up and then I heard a shot.” Lisa Finch, after Wichita police shot her son Andrew, 28, at his door on a hoax call, 2017 (Wichita Eagle, via Newshub)“I can’t breathe. I can’t breathe.” Herman Whitfield III, 39, a pianist in a mental health crisis, face-down in his parents’ Indianapolis living room, 2022 (bodycam, via WRTV)“I told Chuck to wake up and keep fighting.” a Killeen, Texas SWAT officer, on Det. Charles Dinwiddie, shot in a 2014 no-knock raid (trial testimony, via KCEN)“I don’t know if I will ever be able to sleep at night.” Eddie Parker, tortured by Rankin County, Mississippi deputies in a warrantless home raid, 2023 (statement, via the Minneapolis Spokesman-Recorder)“I’m gonna break the door down.” Fort Lee, New Jersey officer Tony Pickens Jr., after a brother called 911 for help with his sister’s mental health crisis, 2024 (bodycam, via NPR)“I’m naked, and you kicked my house in.” Anjanette Young, to the officers (bodycam, via The Hill)Seconds after he fired, one thought: “Did I hit him?” Fountain, Colorado police officer Jon Kay, on the seconds after he shot a man (Colorado Springs Gazette, 2018)“Drop the gun! Drop the gun!” the deputy, after the shots; Fortson’s legally owned gun had been pointed at the floor (bodycam, via NBC Miami)“Bree, oh my God.” Kenneth Walker, on the same call (WDRB)“He’s got a gun!” an officer, after the shots; Locke had a carry permit and was not named in the warrant (bodycam, via WCCO)“If you do that again, we are shooting you.” Sgt. Charles Langley, to Shaver (bodycam transcript, via the Dallas Morning News)“I’m not pulling it out.” Castile, seconds before seven shots (dashcam, via the Star Tribune)“We cannot figure out how to breathe.” Kimberly Dotson, at a news conference (The Journal)“Why would we hurt you? You called us.” Deputy Sean Grayson (bodycam, via The Root)“If I had never dialed the police department, she’d still be alive.” James Smith, the neighbor who asked for a welfare check (AP)“Get up, man.” Guyger, to Botham Jean, before the dispatcher answered (911 call, via Going Concern)“Reshyla is still having nightmares, still can't sleep.” Regina Evans, after Chicago police pointed guns at her young daughters in a raid on the wrong home (Good Morning America, 2021)“He’s pulled a gun on us, ma’am.” the officer (bodycam, via Fox 10)“I’m telling you I’m OK!” Chamberlain, through the door (LifeAid recording, via Democracy Now!)“DOA on Harding.” Houston police radio (via KPRC)“I still have an officer inside the residence.” radio traffic; Deputy Zackari Parrish, 29, a father of two, was still inside (via CBS Colorado)“A vape pen that was found on the bed right next to him.” Columbus Police Chief Elaine Bryant, on what was in his hand (via Yahoo News)“Don’t hurt us!” the Shelton family, when a Denver SWAT team surrounded the wrong apartment, 2023 (via USA Today)“I got an officer shot at this location in the leg!” an officer, to the dispatcher (via the Inquirer)“Fire was being shot all over.” Florence County Sheriff Kenney Boone (NPR)“You killed my son, you killed my son!” Cathy Wallace, his mother (bodycam, via Philadelphia magazine)Fatigue, trouble sleeping, recurring thoughts. what officers reported most often after shooting someone, in a federal study of 80 officers and 113 shootings (National Institute of Justice, 2001)“I’m so sorry!” Win Rozario (bodycam, via Democracy Now!)“They didn’t give him any warnings.” Lisa Finch (via NewsChannel 5)“He was saying fire, fire!” his father, Herman Whitfield Jr., who watched (WRTV)“With my life.” a fellow officer, asked if he trusted Dinwiddie (testimony, via KCEN)“I’m so sorry that I caused that. I hate myself for it.” former deputy Hunter Elward, at sentencing, to Michael Jenkins (via the Spokesman-Recorder)“Who wants to go lethal” officers in the hallway, before Victoria Lee, 25, was shot holding a water jug (bodycam, via CNN)“My name is Anjanette Young. What is going on?” Young, as a blanket kept slipping off her while she stood cuffed (bodycam, via the Daily Dot)“It’s over there.” Roger Fortson, 23, on the floor, about his gun (bodycam, via NBC Miami)“I don’t know, she is on the ground right now.” Walker, asked where Breonna Taylor had been shot (911 call, via theGrio)“She still doesn't sleep.” an Oklahoma City mother whose 9-year-old walked toward armed officers in a raid on the wrong house (News 9, 2025)“A mother should never have to see her child executed…” Karen Wells, Amir Locke’s mother (ABC News, 2022)“You may not survive it, do you understand me?” the commands before Shaver was shot five times with a rifle (bodycam, via Uproxx)“I wasn’t reaching.” Castile, softly, after the shots (dashcam, via Jezebel)“This ending is just unbelievably tragic.” Farmington Police Chief Steve Hebbe (via KION)“Please God, please God, please God.” Sonya Massey (bodycam, via USA Today)“Justice don’t bring my sister back.” Amber Carr, Jefferson’s sister (AP)“I’m gonna lose my job.” Guyger, on the same call (AP)“Because it’s dark and someone has knocked on the door.” Nees, explaining why he answered armed (bodycam, via Fox 10)“I have the White Plains Police Department banging on my door” Chamberlain, to the LifeAid operator (via Truthout)Nightmares. Flashbacks. Sirens in his ears for three days. a 22-year police veteran and SWAT operator, after a shooting; he could not talk about it with his own wife, also an officer (Police1)“Got three officers hit.” Houston police radio (via KHOU)“They tried to pull him out but were unable to.” Sheriff Tony Spurlock, on the wounded deputies (Denver Post)“As a parent, you know, I sympathize and I grieve with his mother.” Chief Bryant (via BET)“Nothing short of a miracle that we don’t have multiple officers killed today.” Philadelphia’s police commissioner (via Firehouse)“Seemed like it was forever.” Florence Police Chief Allen Heidler, on the wait to reach the wounded (AP)“Shoot him.” an unidentified male voice on the bodycam audio (via NPR)“Get her out of the way!” NYPD officers, as his mother held on to him (bodycam, via AP)“Adelina was made to step over his dying body.” Lisa Finch, on her granddaughter, who saw it happen (via Dazed)“I was just horrified.” his father (WRTV)“Every little noise is like, ‘who's out there?’” a Detroit mother after police raided her family's home looking for a man who no longer lived there (WXYZ)“I knew what I did was wrong.” a Killeen officer, testifying that he put his pistol in Marvin Guy’s mouth after the raid (KCEN)“I hate what’s happened to them.” Elward (via Mississippi Today and the New York Times)“I truly believe they would have shot me.” Anjanette Young, later (CBS 2 Chicago, via HuffPost)“I can’t breathe.” Roger Fortson, according to his family’s lawyer, who cited the girlfriend on FaceTime with him (via Complex)“I can’t stand up because I’m going to pump the blood out.” Sgt. Jonathan Mattingly, shot in the leg in the doorway (interview with ABC News and the Courier Journal, 2020)“And now his dreams have been destroyed.” Karen Wells (Daily Herald)“My kids are absolutely heartbroken, and I can’t fix it.” Laney Sweet, Shaver’s widow and the mother of their two girls (ABC10)“You just killed my boyfriend.” Diamond Reynolds, from the passenger seat (dashcam, via CBS News)“I rebuke you in the name of Jesus.” Massey, at her stove (bodycam, via the Chicago Reporter)Her children dream the SWAT team kills their mother. a Denver family's lawsuit over a wrong-apartment SWAT raid; one daughter still sleeps in her mother's room (Atlanta Black Star, 2025)“My daughter… had her whole life in front of her.” Marquis Jefferson (CBS News)“I’m so tired.” Guyger, on the same call (AP)“He stepped out of the door, realized it was them, put his hand down.” Steven Whitaker, his brother (Arizona Republic)“They have stun guns and shotguns!” Chamberlain (Taser camera, via Democracy Now!)“I had to get in there because I knew my guys were down.” a 54-year-old officer, shot for the third time in his career (note to his chief, via ABC13)“Murdered him in our kitchen without any care for him or us.” the Rozario family’s statement (via Yahoo News)“My innocent son being shot through the screen door…” Lisa Finch, to the Wichita City Council (via The Appeal)“I miss his hugs.” his mother, Gladys Whitfield (WRTV)“I never heard “police search warrant.”” Joanna Humfleet, Guy’s neighbor (testimony, via KCEN)Nightmares, suicidal thoughts, symptoms that fit PTSD. what people described after law enforcement raids on their homes, in the first study of raids' psychological impact (Traumatology, 2018)“Did she have a gun? Was she a shooter?” Mattingly’s first question on waking from surgery the next day (ABC News)“My son Amir was a law-abiding citizen who did not have a criminal history.” Andre Locke, his father (ABC News)“Don’t move, baby.” Reynolds, to her 4-year-old daughter in the back seat (dashcam, via the Tri-State Defender)“I’ll f—ing shoot you right in the f—ing face.” Deputy Grayson, drawing his pistol (bodycam, via Capitol News Illinois)“White Plains police are going to come in here and kill me.” Chamberlain, before they broke down the door and shot him (via Common Dreams)“He woke up happy.” Holly Dinwiddie, the detective’s widow (testimony, via Reason)“Breonna Taylor is now attached to me for the rest of my life.” Mattingly (ABC News)“I don’t know how many rounds I let out.” Officer Jeronimo Yanez, afterward (dashcam, via Fox 2 Detroit)“OK, I’m sorry!” Sonya Massey, ducking, seconds before she was shot (bodycam, via USA Today)She taught her children to respect police. Now they fear them. Ebony Tate, after a Chicago SWAT team raided the wrong home (Fox 32 Chicago)“His wife, his children deserve justice.” Kathryn Dinwiddie, his sister (KCEN)He thought fellow officers were “being executed.” Det. Brett Hankison, explaining why he fired blindly into the apartment (grand jury recordings, via CNN)“That’s a headshot. There’s nothing you can do, man.” Grayson, telling his partner not to bother with the medical kit (bodycam, via AP)About 1 in 4 had elevated post-traumatic stress. children who had watched a household member arrested and had a recently arrested parent, in a national study (Children and Youth Services Review, 2010)
    Read all